Discovery of dog saves man from sex-crime conviction, 50-year prison sentence

A man from Oregon has been exonerated from what would have been a 50-year prison sentence after the discovery of a black lab named Lucy lead to the unraveling of the District Attorney’s case. Joshua Horner, a plumber from Redmond, OR, was convicted of sexual abuse of a minor in 2017. The alleged victim in the case had testified that Horner threatened to shoot her animals if she spoke to the police about the alleged molestation. She then claimed that Horner actually shot and killed Lucy the black lab to make his point. After being convicted by a non-unanimous jury, Horner turned to the Oregon Innocence Project for help. The group immediately set out to look for Lucy, as Horner insisted he never shot the dog. Finding Lucy was no easy task, but the Innocence Project was aided by the Deschutes County District Attorney’s office, who had agreed to work with the group after they raised concerns about Horner’s case. Finally, Lucy was found in a town Northwest of Portland called Gearhart. She was alive and well, meaning the accuser had lied in her testimony. This forced the District Attorney’s office to reconsider their stance, and soon enough Horner’s conviction was reversed, and another trial ordered. The alleged victim from the case has since been uncooperative with the District Attorney’s office, and Horner will no longer have to go to the second trial. This was the first exoneration achieved by the Oregon Innocence Project, who was established in 2014. The Law Offices of Steven J Pisani specialize in DUI, traffic, and criminal defense. Call our Denver office today for a free consultation at 303-635-6768.


NY Post, Associated Press, September 11th, 2018


Contact our firm today for a free consultation

Our Services

Criminal Defense

Criminal Defense Attorney represents defendants at all stages of the criminal process for both misdemeanors and felonies...

Read more

DUI Defense

Denver DUI Attorney Steven J. Pisani represents individuals charged with driving under the influence and alcohol-related traffic...

Read more

Domestic Violence

Denver Domestic Violence Defense Attorney Steven J. Pisani represents individuals charged with domestic violence offenses in Colorado...

Read more

Traffic Tickets

Denver Traffic Attorney Steven J. Pisani effectively represents clients who have been charged with a traffic offense. Traffic laws are typically...

Read more

Read Client Reviews


We provide full-service legal assistance with specialization in criminal defense representation, domestic violence defense, DUI defense (driving under the influence), Colorado traffic tickets, Drunk Driving, juvenile criminal defense, shoplifting defense and sealing of criminal records...

Read Reviews

Customer Reviews

Recent News

322 Colorado drivers arrested on suspicion of DUI Memorial Day weekend

Between May 24 and May 28, 2019, Colorado police arrested 322 people suspected of DUI. This number is higher than […]

Read more

Tracy Morgan’s Bugatti Sideswiped 15 Mins After Driving Off the Lot!!!

Tracy Morgan was sideswiped 15 minutes after driving his brand- new $2.5 million Bugatti off the dealer lot. This incident […]

Read more

New Colorado law increases penalties for drivers who hit bicyclists, pedestrians and construction workers

Governor Jared Polis signed Senate Bill 175. With the new bill, a driver who hits a vulnerable road user (bicyclist, […]

Read more