Serving People Throughout Colorado

Call Us For Free Consultation:

In Colorado criminal cases, police body camera footage can be the turning point between a conviction and a dismissal of the charge. With law enforcement agencies across the state, including in Denver, now required to wear and activate body cameras during most public interactions, this digital evidence has become central to building a strong defense strategy.

But here’s the truth: body camera footage doesn’t always tell the whole story—and sometimes, it gets withheld, misrepresented, or mysteriously “lost.”

At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we understand how to leverage this critical evidence to our clients’ advantage. With over a decade of experience in Denver criminal defense, Attorney Steven J. Pisani has reviewed countless hours of police video, exposing inconsistencies, highlighting civil rights violations, and challenging the narrative presented by law enforcement.

“In today’s courtroom, body cam footage is often treated as the final word. But we know how to ask the right questions and put the footage in context,” Pisani says.

Our firm’s commitment to criminal defense and traffic-related cases in Denver isn’t just professional—it’s personal. Clients trust us because we don’t just accept what’s on tape; we investigate every frame.

As one recent client shared, “Pisani Law took the time to break down the body cam video and found details even I missed. That changed everything in my case.”

Understanding the role of police video in your case starts here—with the truth, your rights, and a legal team that knows how to use both.

Colorado’s Commitment to Transparency Through Body Cams

Colorado is at the forefront of police accountability reform, and police body camera laws are a significant part of that shift. In 2020, state lawmakers passed Senate Bill 20-217, known as the Enhanced Law Enforcement Integrity Act. This law requires nearly all Colorado law enforcement officers, including those in Denver, to wear and activate body cameras during any interaction with the public that could lead to enforcement action.

But simply wearing a camera isn’t enough. The law sets strict standards for when the camera must be turned on, how long footage must be retained, and what happens if that footage is tampered with or goes missing.

Key Requirements Under Colorado Law

If you’ve been charged with a crime in Denver, here’s what the law says about body camera use:

  • Recording Required: Officers must activate their body-worn cameras during interactions involving suspected criminal activity, arrests, searches, or the use of force.
  • Footage Retention: Video must be retained for at least 90 days, and up to three years if it involves a complaint or use of force.
  • Tampering Penalties: If an officer is found to have intentionally turned off, destroyed, or altered body cam footage, it can result in criminal penalties and disciplinary action.
  • Disclosure Rules: The footage must be disclosed to the public within 21 days if it captures an incident involving alleged misconduct or the use of excessive force.

According to a 2023 Colorado Criminal Defense Bar report, over 18% of complaints against officers involved missing or incomplete body cam footage—a growing concern that can significantly affect a defendant’s rights.

Why This Matters to You

At Pisani Law, we use this legal framework to hold law enforcement accountable and ensure our clients’ rights aren’t violated behind a lens. Attorney Steven J. Pisani routinely challenges incomplete or improperly handled video footage and knows how to file suppression motions when officers fail to comply with state laws. These technical violations can be the difference between a full conviction and a reduced or dismissed charge.

When your future is on the line, you need a criminal defense attorney in Denver who not only understands the law but also knows how to use it to protect you.

Can Body Camera Footage Help or Hurt Your Criminal Case? 

Criminal defense lawyer in Denver

Police body camera footage in Colorado can be one of the most potent pieces of evidence in your criminal case—but it can either help you or hurt you, depending on how it’s used and interpreted.

At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we’ve seen body cam evidence expose constitutional violations, discredit officer testimony, and result in charges being dropped. We’ve also seen prosecutors attempt to use selectively presented footage to paint a misleading picture.

Understanding how to use body cam footage strategically is essential—and that’s where we come in.

How Body Cam Footage Can Help You

With over a decade of experience as a Denver criminal lawyer, Attorney Steven J. Pisani has used video evidence to defend clients facing charges such as assault, DUI, obstruction, and drug possession. Here’s how body cam footage can support your defense:

  • Proves Your Side of the Story: Footage may show you were calm or compliant, countering police claims of aggression or resistance.
  • Reveals Illegal Searches: If an officer searched you or your property without probable cause, the footage may provide grounds to suppress evidence.
  • Documents Use of Force: In excessive force claims, video can clearly show whether a police officer’s actions were unreasonable.
  • Shows Miranda Violations: If you weren’t read your rights or were questioned after asking for a lawyer, it may be caught on tape.

When It Can Hurt Your Case

However, not all footage works in your favor:

  • Out-of-Context Clips: Prosecutors may use short clips that don’t show the whole story.
  • Muffled Audio or Obstructed Views: Poor-quality footage may create ambiguity, and police reports can “fill in the gaps” in their favor.
  • Unflattering Behavior: If you appeared agitated or used strong language, that footage can be used to influence a jury.

“We don’t just watch the video—we break it down frame by frame,” says Steven J. Pisani. “It’s not about what’s obvious. It’s about what’s missing, what’s manipulated, and what’s misunderstood.”

This is where legal skill matters. We know how to challenge video evidence, request complete footage, and present it in a way that highlights your rights, not your worst moments.

What Happens If the Police Don’t Have or Won’t Share the Footage?

It’s a common question we hear at The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani: What if the police say they don’t have the body camera footage? In many Colorado criminal cases, footage that should exist suddenly becomes “unavailable,” “corrupted,” or “never recorded.” When that happens, you need an attorney who understands how to respond strategically and effectively, both legally and tactically.

Under Colorado law, officers are required to activate their body cams during nearly all public interactions that may lead to law enforcement action. If they fail to do so—or if the footage “disappears”—this may signal a violation of your constitutional rights, including due process under the 14th Amendment.

Legal Options When Footage Is Missing

If body camera footage is missing, mishandled, or intentionally withheld, our team can take decisive action:

  • File a Motion to Compel Discovery: We formally request that the prosecution disclose any existing footage and metadata.
  • Challenge Admissibility of Other Evidence: If video evidence is lost, we may argue that other parts of the prosecution’s case (like officer testimony) should be suppressed.
  • Request Jury Instructions About Missing Evidence: In some cases, courts may instruct the jury that the missing evidence would have been favorable to the defendant.
  • File a Motion to Dismiss Charges: When the missing footage is critical, dismissal may be warranted due to prosecutorial misconduct or destruction of evidence.

In a 2022 Pisani Law case, body cam footage mysteriously went missing in a misdemeanor assault charge. Our legal team filed a motion to suppress the officer’s testimony, and the charges were dismissed before trial.

This isn’t about a technicality. It’s about justice. And in Colorado courts, we fight for it every step of the way.

Real-World Case Examples: Body Cam Footage That Changed the Outcome

At Pisani Law, we don’t just talk about results—we deliver them. Body camera footage has played a pivotal role in several of our Denver criminal defense cases, often making the difference between conviction and dismissal.

These real-world examples demonstrate the power of video evidence when carefully reviewed, strategically challenged, and placed in the proper legal context.

Case Example 1: Assault Charge Dismissed After Body Cam Review

Our client was charged with misdemeanor assault after a late-night incident outside a Denver bar. The police report painted a one-sided picture of aggression, claiming the defendant had initiated the altercation. However, after securing the full body cam footage, we uncovered several inconsistencies:

  • The video showed that the alleged victim was the initial aggressor.
  • Officers failed to read Miranda rights to the suspect before questioning.
  • Critical comments by officers contradicted the official report.

The footage told a different story, and once we presented it to the prosecution, all charges were dropped.

Case Example 2: DUI Charge Reduced After Video Analysis

In a DUI case, police claimed our client was slurring speech and failing field sobriety tests. Body cam footage revealed:

  • The officer interrupted instructions during the test.
  • Our client’s speech was clear, and they appeared cooperative.
  • The initial traffic stop was based on a vague and unsupported claim.

We filed a motion to suppress the stop based on lack of probable cause, and the prosecutor agreed to reduce the charge to a traffic infraction.

Why These Examples Matter

Many law firms stop at watching the footage. We analyze it frame-by-frame. At Pisani Law, we understand how to extract the truth from shaky angles, muffled audio, and incomplete records—and we use that truth to protect our clients.

Because in the courtroom, video evidence doesn’t win cases—strategy does.

Your Rights Regarding Police Body Cameras in Colorado

Police body cameras may seem like a neutral record of events, but in reality, they’re tools subject to human error, officer discretion, and legal interpretation. As a defendant or someone under investigation in Colorado, it’s crucial to understand your rights when it comes to accessing and using police body cam footage.

At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we help clients exercise these rights fully and strategically from the start.

You Have a Right to Access Relevant Footage

Under Colorado’s Body-Worn Camera Law (SB20-217) and the Colorado Open Records Act (CORA), you may be entitled to request and obtain footage in the following ways:

  • Through Criminal Discovery: If you’re facing charges, your criminal defense attorney can demand relevant footage during the discovery process. This is the most effective and direct way to obtain the body camera videos related to your arrest or alleged incident.
  • Public Access (in Some Cases): If an incident involves serious misconduct or public concern, the law requires footage to be released within 21 days. However, this typically applies to civil rights-related incidents, not routine arrests.
  • Through a CORA Request: Members of the public—including criminal defense teams—can request footage through the state’s open records process. However, access is not always guaranteed, and redactions may apply.

Common Misunderstandings About Body Cam Access

Many people believe:

  • “If the police have video, I automatically get to see it.”
    – Not always true. The prosecution must turn it over in discovery, but delays and resistance are common.
  • “They’ll give me all the footage from that day.”
    – Officers may only release the portion directly related to the charges, unless your attorney fights for the rest.
  • “If there’s no footage, I can’t do anything about it.”
    – On the contrary, missing footage may strengthen your case if legal procedures weren’t followed.

“Your right to see the footage is only as strong as your lawyer’s willingness to demand it,” says Attorney Steven J. Pisani. “We don’t wait. We act—fast and aggressively—because your defense may depend on a single frame.”

Knowing your rights is the first step. The next step is hiring a defense attorney who will fight to enforce them.

How Pisani Law Analyzes and Challenges Body Camera Evidence

At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we treat body camera footage as a key piece of the puzzle, not the entire picture. While many defense attorneys simply watch the footage and move on, our approach is meticulous, layered, and rooted in over a decade of experience defending clients in Denver criminal courts. We don’t assume the footage tells the whole story—we investigate how it was captured, what’s missing, and how it’s being used.

Our Step-by-Step Strategy for Analyzing Body Cam Footage

When body camera evidence is involved in a case, here’s how our team gets to work:

  • Request the Raw Footage and Metadata: We don’t just accept the prosecution’s version—we demand the full, unedited video, along with file data such as timestamps and device logs.
  • Synchronize Audio and Video Across Multiple Cameras: In multi-officer incidents, syncing body cam footage can reveal inconsistencies in what each officer reported or how events unfolded.
  • Analyze for Protocol Violations: We verify whether officers activated cameras on time, kept them running during the encounter, and complied with Colorado’s legal requirements.
  • Compare Footage Against Police Reports: Our team frequently uncovers discrepancies between the video and the official arrest narrative.
  • Use Expert Forensic Review (When Needed): In complex or high-stakes cases, we may retain audio/video forensic experts to clarify what can or can’t be seen, enhancing our client’s position.

Why This Matters in Court

Prosecutors often present body cam footage as “undeniable proof.” But what the jury sees—or doesn’t see—depends entirely on how well your defense team prepares. If angles are obscured, key moments are cut, or footage was recorded after crucial events, we make sure those facts come to light.

In one recent Denver case, our review revealed that officers muted their body mics during a critical part of an arrest. That omission helped us file a motion to suppress the client’s statements, significantly weakening the prosecution’s case.

With Pisani Law, you get more than a defense—you get a detailed, evidence-driven strategy built around your rights, your story, and the truth.

What to Do If You Believe the Body Cam Footage Was Mishandled

If you suspect that police officers failed to record, intentionally altered, or concealed body camera footage during your arrest or investigation, time is not on your side. Mishandled footage isn’t just a technical problem—it can represent a serious violation of your constitutional rights. At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we act quickly and decisively to preserve evidence and challenge any misconduct before it’s buried by bureaucracy.

Immediate Steps You Should Take

Denver, Colorado criminal lawyer

If you have any reason to believe the footage was mishandled, take the following steps right away:

  • Don’t Wait to Speak to an Attorney: Time is critical. Footage can be overwritten, lost, or “accidentally” deleted if not preserved. We move fast to demand retention.
  • Document Everything You Remember: Write down the date, time, and location of the incident, as well as the names of any officers or witnesses. These details help us identify which cameras should have been recording.
  • Request Discovery Early: Once retained, our firm files immediate discovery motions to force the prosecution to turn over body camera footage, dispatch logs, and related evidence.
  • Push for a Forensic Review: If footage appears altered, we can retain forensic experts to review timecodes, video quality, and inconsistencies that could support a motion to suppress.

Legal Remedies for Mishandled Footage

In cases where body camera footage is mishandled, we may pursue the following legal options:

  • Motion to Suppress Evidence: If footage of a critical moment is missing, the court may rule that specific evidence (or the entire arrest) is inadmissible.
  • Motion for Sanctions: We can request that the judge penalize the prosecution or police for bad-faith conduct.
  • Motion to Dismiss: If the missing footage significantly impacts your ability to present a fair defense, dismissal of charges may be appropriate.

“We don’t just ask where the footage is—we ask why it’s missing, who had access, and what else they’re not showing,” says Attorney Steven J. Pisani.

You only get one shot at defending your rights. Make sure the evidence is on your side—and in the right hands.

Protecting Your Rights 

Police body camera footage in Colorado criminal cases is powerful—but it’s not always clear, complete, or fairly used. What appears on video can shape the outcome of your case, but only if it’s analyzed and challenged by a defense attorney who knows the system inside and out. At The Law Offices of Steven J. Pisani, we’ve spent over a decade defending the rights of individuals in Denver, and we know how to expose the gaps between what’s shown and what’s true.

From identifying missing footage to discrediting misleading clips, we approach every case with strategy, speed, and precision. Attorney Steven J. Pisani doesn’t take shortcuts when it comes to your future—he digs deep, challenges everything, and fights smart.

If you’re facing criminal charges and believe body cam footage plays a role in your case—or should have—don’t wait. You need legal representation that understands both the technology and the tactics behind the video.

/

Request a FREE Case Review