Judge: Victim’s Mom Not to Cry in Hernandez Trial

The judge overseeing the murder trial of ex- New England Patriots Tight End Aaron Hernandez warned the victim’s mother to not cry on the stand in front of jurors Wednesday, a reference to the two previous days she left the courtroom in tears when seeing photos of her son’s body at the morgue.

I have been on the other side of the crying and emotional witness before, in criminal cases with far less severe and less horrific outcomes than this case. As a defense attorney, there is a fine line to walk with an emotional witness; you do not want to be too abrasive but you still need questions answered and our theory has to come across with the jury. To our chagrin, the judges generally give wide latitudes to a witness and their emotions as long as they are responsive and not a disruption.

In this case, the judge may be harsher on the witnesses because the prosecution’s case has been largely circumstantial. No direct evidence has been or will be introduced. There is no offer of the murder weapon, no offer of a witness to the crime. No offer of a motive for the killing and no forensics linking Mr. Hernandez to the commission of the crime.

The fact is the prosecution has a weak case in a capital crime prosecution. It is possible that emotional testimony could subliminally be the deciding factor.

The judge knows this and he does not like it. One man lost his life and another stands to lose his freedom- the outcome should be based on  tangible evidence, not the emotions of an obviously grieving and weeping mother.

From what I have read of the evidence I have little doubt Hernandez participated in the killing,  but I don’t think capitalizing on emotion is the correct way to go to gain a conviction.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

2 × two =

Contact our firm today for a free consultation

Our Services

Criminal Defense

Criminal Defense Attorney represents defendants at all stages of the criminal process for both misdemeanors and felonies...

Read more

DUI Defense

Denver DUI Attorney Steven J. Pisani represents individuals charged with driving under the influence and alcohol-related traffic...

Read more

Domestic Violence

Denver Domestic Violence Defense Attorney Steven J. Pisani represents individuals charged with domestic violence offenses in Colorado...

Read more

Traffic Tickets

Denver Traffic Attorney Steven J. Pisani effectively represents clients who have been charged with a traffic offense. Traffic laws are typically...

Read more

Read Client Reviews


We provide full-service legal assistance with specialization in criminal defense representation, domestic violence defense, DUI defense (driving under the influence), Colorado traffic tickets, Drunk Driving, juvenile criminal defense, shoplifting defense and sealing of criminal records...

Read Reviews

Customer Reviews

Recent News

Man fights distracted driving ticket; says McDonald’s hash brown was mistaken for cell phone

A man in Westport, Connecticut is currently fighting a traffic ticket for distracted driving. His defense? That he was actually […]

Read more

Woman jailed 3 months because police thought her cotton candy was meth

Dasha Fincher spent three months in jail after two Georgia deputies said a field test of a blue substance found […]

Read more

Here’s what was found in background checks of Colorado statehouse candidates

The Denver Post recently ran background checks for all of the candidates for Colorado’s General Assembly. Certain Colorado criminal records […]

Read more